{
  "schema": "report-v2",
  "project": {
    "project_id": "VCS2505",
    "project_name": "Fuel Efficient Cooking in South Africa",
    "registry_url": "https://registry.verra.org/app/projectDetail/VCS/2505",
    "methodology": "VMR0006",
    "methodology_version": null
  },
  "document": {
    "file_name": "Fuel Efficient Cooking in South Africa Grouped PDD_v9_Clean.pdf",
    "sha256": "1d09240addf6b933de31de7492b798775ddf16183425b8d0eff00e6f0e5d810a",
    "pages": 64
  },
  "methodology_status": {
    "code": "VMR0006",
    "version": null,
    "status": "not_ccp_approved",
    "summary": "No CCP approval for VMR0006. ICVCM approved Verra's successor cookstove methodology VM0050 v1.0 with conditions that constrain fNRB and require stricter fuel-use monitoring.",
    "sources": [
      "https://icvcm.org/integrity-council-approves-three-cookstove-methodologies/",
      "https://www.calyxglobal.com/research-hub/research/how-the-ICVCM-CCP-labels-are-raising-the-quality-of-cookstoves-and-household-biodigester-projects"
    ],
    "table_version": "2026-10-15"
  },
  "method": {
    "report_schema": "report-v2",
    "question_set_version": "qs-v2-checklist",
    "prompt_version": "checklist-v1",
    "evidence_rule": "yes-cites-excerpt-paragraph-v2",
    "excerpt_rule": "select_paragraphs(budget_chars=30000, overview_chars=0)",
    "llm_model": "deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash",
    "second_opinion_model": "typesafe/jev-1.13",
    "methodology_table_version": "2026-10-15",
    "pdf_extractor": "pymupdf 1.28.2"
  },
  "method_hash": "0xcbc09ba01911f0718fbc17bbfdb895ca5c498e02f8b51522917086118532df35",
  "principles": [
    {
      "principle": "additionality",
      "status": "partial_evidence",
      "score": 25,
      "rationale": "Evidence found for 1 of 4 checks (A3); not found in the excerpt: A1, A2, A4.",
      "checks": [
        {
          "id": "A1",
          "question": "Does the text report a quantified financial analysis: at least one numeric financial indicator (such as IRR or NPV) together with a benchmark or threshold value it is compared against?",
          "answer": "no",
          "evidence": [],
          "second_opinion_p_yes": 0.02,
          "needs_review": false,
          "dropped": null
        },
        {
          "id": "A2",
          "question": "Does the text discuss common practice, i.e. whether similar activities are already widespread in the region or sector?",
          "answer": "no",
          "evidence": [],
          "second_opinion_p_yes": 0.61,
          "needs_review": true,
          "dropped": null
        },
        {
          "id": "A3",
          "question": "Does the text state that the project activity is not required by any law or regulation (regulatory surplus)?",
          "answer": "yes",
          "evidence": [
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p8-19",
              "page": 8,
              "text": "1. There \nis \nno \ngovernment \nmandated programme or policy \nin South Africa ensuring the \ndistribution \nof \nnew \nproject \nactivity \ninstances \nor \nfuel \nefficient cookstoves."
            }
          ],
          "second_opinion_p_yes": 0.66,
          "needs_review": false,
          "dropped": null
        },
        {
          "id": "A4",
          "question": "Does the text state that carbon credit revenue was considered before or at the start of the project (prior consideration), for example with a date or a document?",
          "answer": "no",
          "evidence": [],
          "second_opinion_p_yes": 0.1,
          "needs_review": false,
          "dropped": null
        }
      ],
      "quotes": [
        {
          "text": "1. There \nis \nno \ngovernment \nmandated programme or policy \nin South Africa ensuring the \ndistribution \nof \nnew \nproject \nactivity \ninstances \nor \nfuel \nefficient cookstoves.",
          "page": 8,
          "paragraph_id": "p8-19",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        }
      ],
      "dropped_findings": 0,
      "review_flags": [
        "models_disagree:A2"
      ],
      "excerpt": {
        "paragraphs": [
          "p2-18",
          "p2-19",
          "p2-20",
          "p2-29",
          "p2-30",
          "p2-31",
          "p3-01",
          "p5-08",
          "p5-09",
          "p5-10",
          "p8-05",
          "p8-06",
          "p8-11",
          "p8-12",
          "p8-13",
          "p8-14",
          "p8-16",
          "p8-17",
          "p8-19",
          "p8-20",
          "p8-21",
          "p9-07",
          "p9-08",
          "p9-11",
          "p9-12",
          "p9-13",
          "p14-03",
          "p14-04",
          "p15-05",
          "p15-06",
          "p17-08",
          "p17-09",
          "p20-05",
          "p20-06",
          "p21-07",
          "p21-08",
          "p26-02",
          "p26-03",
          "p27-03",
          "p27-04",
          "p27-05",
          "p33-02",
          "p33-03",
          "p43-06",
          "p43-07",
          "p44-03",
          "p44-04",
          "p45-07",
          "p45-15",
          "p45-16",
          "p47-11",
          "p47-12",
          "p47-13",
          "p47-14",
          "p50-10",
          "p50-11",
          "p50-12",
          "p50-13",
          "p50-14",
          "p51-02",
          "p51-03",
          "p51-04",
          "p55-08",
          "p55-09",
          "p56-09",
          "p56-10",
          "p56-11",
          "p57-08",
          "p57-09",
          "p57-10",
          "p58-09",
          "p58-10"
        ],
        "chars": 14686
      }
    },
    {
      "principle": "permanence",
      "status": "not_applicable",
      "score": null,
      "rationale": "Emission-avoidance activity without stored carbon at risk of reversal; permanence is not applicable (rule based on project category, not AI).",
      "checks": [],
      "quotes": [],
      "dropped_findings": 0,
      "review_flags": [],
      "rule": "no_reversal_risk"
    },
    {
      "principle": "robust_quantification",
      "status": "strong_evidence",
      "score": 100,
      "rationale": "Evidence found for 4 of 4 checks (Q1, Q2, Q3, Q4).",
      "checks": [
        {
          "id": "Q1",
          "question": "Does the text show how baseline emissions are calculated, with an equation, parameter values or a numeric result?",
          "answer": "yes",
          "evidence": [
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p50-12",
              "page": 50,
              "text": "In order to calculate the ex-ante annual quantity of biomass that would have been used in \nthe absence of project activity to generate useful thermal energy equivalent to that provided \nby the ICS (Bold), the parameters and estimates are used from the first planned PI: PI1-K2C, \noutlined below."
            },
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p50-13",
              "page": 50,
              "text": "A PI-level analysis for PI1-K2C, has been provided below for the GP’s ex-ante emissions \nreductions calculations."
            },
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p50-20",
              "page": 50,
              "text": "Efwf,CO2 \ntCO2e/TJ \n112 \nCO2 emission factor of \nbiomass that is substituted \nor reduced"
            },
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p50-22",
              "page": 50,
              "text": "Efwf,non-CO2 \ntCO2e/TJ \n26.23 \nNon-CO2 emission factor of \nbiomass that is substituted \nor reduced"
            },
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p50-31",
              "page": 50,
              "text": "Bold \ntonnes/year \n5.49 \nQuantity of biomass \nconsumed in baseline"
            }
          ],
          "second_opinion_p_yes": 0.8,
          "needs_review": false,
          "dropped": null
        },
        {
          "id": "Q2",
          "question": "Does the text address leakage (emissions shifted outside the project boundary), either by quantifying it or by justifying why it is zero?",
          "answer": "yes",
          "evidence": [
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p21-10",
              "page": 21,
              "text": "The project adopts a gross-to-net adjustment factor of 95% on emissions reductions to \naccount for leakage as described under the methodology VMR0006, Section 8.3."
            },
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p46-08",
              "page": 46,
              "text": "Leakage shall be considered as default 0.95 in accordance with Section 8.3 of the applied \nmethodology VRM0006 v1."
            },
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p47-15",
              "page": 47,
              "text": "0.95 \nDiscount factor to account for leakage."
            },
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p48-16",
              "page": 48,
              "text": "A net gross leakage factor of 0.95 is applied to ERy,i,j."
            },
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p50-30",
              "page": 50,
              "text": "DF \nfraction \n0.95 \nDefault leakage adjustment \nfactor"
            }
          ],
          "second_opinion_p_yes": 0.94,
          "needs_review": false,
          "dropped": null
        },
        {
          "id": "Q3",
          "question": "Does the text address uncertainty or the use of conservative assumptions in the emission reduction estimate?",
          "answer": "yes",
          "evidence": [
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p15-04",
              "page": 15,
              "text": "from PI1-K2C. Based on the initial number of ICS planned for PI1-K2C and taking the \nexpected 5-year operational lifetime of the ICS into account, the GP’s ex-ante ERs were \nmodelled to represent a conservative approximation. Although the expected lifetime of the \ntechnology is 5 years, it is assumed that some of the devices will still be operational after \nthe 5-year period. For ex-ante estimations, a decreasing operation rate of stoves (“drop off \nrate”) of 2.5% per year was incorporated into the ER calculation for the 10-year crediting \nperiod."
            },
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p48-06",
              "page": 48,
              "text": "0.94 \nAdjustment factor to account for uncertainty related to \nproject cookstove efficiency test."
            },
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p55-08",
              "page": 55,
              "text": "Data from the monitoring survey will be collected at least \nbiennially and applied to the emissions reductions \ncalculations during that monitoring period. Where the required \nlevel of precision is not met either additional surveys may be \ncompleted, or the lower bound value applied."
            },
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p56-10",
              "page": 56,
              "text": "Where the required level of precision is not met either \nadditional monitoring activities may be completed, or the lower \nbound value applied."
            },
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p57-09",
              "page": 57,
              "text": "Where the required level of precision is not met either \nadditional monitoring activities may be completed, or the lower \nbound value applied."
            },
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p58-09",
              "page": 58,
              "text": "Data from the monitoring survey will be collected at least \nonce every two years and applied to the emissions reductions \ncalculations during that monitoring period. Where the required \nlevel of precision is not met either additional surveys may be \ncompleted, or the lower bound value applied."
            },
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p64-02",
              "page": 64,
              "text": "If the required level of precision is not achieved, then further surveys may be completed or the \nlower bound value adopted in the calculations."
            }
          ],
          "second_opinion_p_yes": 0.97,
          "needs_review": false,
          "dropped": null
        },
        {
          "id": "Q4",
          "question": "Does the text describe a monitoring plan that names the parameters to be measured and how often or by what method?",
          "answer": "yes",
          "evidence": [
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p54-20",
              "page": 54,
              "text": "The total number of devices in operation compared to the total \nnumber of distributed (according to the monitoring database) \nwill be surveyed."
            },
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p54-22",
              "page": 54,
              "text": "Devices in operation in the sampled group will be counted \nduring each monitoring period to derive an attrition rate \n(expressed as a percentage) and this percentage deduction \nwill be applied to the total number of devices operating."
            },
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p55-08",
              "page": 55,
              "text": "Data from the monitoring survey will be collected at least \nbiennially and applied to the emissions reductions \ncalculations during that monitoring period. Where the required \nlevel of precision is not met either additional surveys may be \ncompleted, or the lower bound value applied."
            },
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p56-06",
              "page": 56,
              "text": "Monitoring equipment \nWhen measured: as specified in WBT protocol"
            },
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p56-09",
              "page": 56,
              "text": "Data will be collected annually and applied to the emissions \nreductions calculations during that monitoring period."
            },
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p57-06",
              "page": 57,
              "text": "Monitoring equipment \nAs specified in KPT protocol"
            },
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p58-09",
              "page": 58,
              "text": "Data from the monitoring survey will be collected at least \nonce every two years and applied to the emissions reductions \ncalculations during that monitoring period. Where the required \nlevel of precision is not met either additional surveys may be \ncompleted, or the lower bound value applied."
            },
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p60-15",
              "page": 60,
              "text": "The actual operation of stoves is monitored via parameter \n𝑵𝑵𝑵𝑵,𝒊𝒊,𝒋𝒋 and therefore any stove found to be in operation beyond \nits expected lifetime may still be credited during the PI crediting \nperiod. Likewise, stoves found not to be in operation prior to \nthe end of their lifetime will be discounted."
            },
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p63-05",
              "page": 63,
              "text": "Field-based monitoring activities to determine monitored parameter values will be either a field \nsurvey, KPT or WBT."
            },
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p63-06",
              "page": 63,
              "text": "Data shall be recorded for each activity either directly onto a smartphone-based app designed for \nthe purpose, or via paper forms where this is not possible."
            },
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p63-10",
              "page": 63,
              "text": "Data collection will be conducted by a dedicated monitoring team of trained individuals, either from \nTASC SA or the Project Instance Implementer. The monitoring team will use a survey \nquestionnaire and instruments required for KPT/WBT measurements on the sampled ICS."
            },
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p64-05",
              "page": 64,
              "text": "Completed survey questionnaires and KPT/WBT data will be collected by the monitoring team and \ndelivered to the TASC SA Carbon Project Manager for analysis. These shall be checked through \nfor errors and completeness, and compiled into a monitoring report. Any incomplete or missing \ndata shall be documented clearly. The monitoring report will include:"
            }
          ],
          "second_opinion_p_yes": 0.97,
          "needs_review": false,
          "dropped": null
        }
      ],
      "quotes": [
        {
          "text": "In order to calculate the ex-ante annual quantity of biomass that would have been used in \nthe absence of project activity to generate useful thermal energy equivalent to that provided \nby the ICS (Bold), the parameters and estimates are used from the first planned PI: PI1-K2C, \noutlined below.",
          "page": 50,
          "paragraph_id": "p50-12",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        },
        {
          "text": "A PI-level analysis for PI1-K2C, has been provided below for the GP’s ex-ante emissions \nreductions calculations.",
          "page": 50,
          "paragraph_id": "p50-13",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        },
        {
          "text": "Efwf,CO2 \ntCO2e/TJ \n112 \nCO2 emission factor of \nbiomass that is substituted \nor reduced",
          "page": 50,
          "paragraph_id": "p50-20",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        },
        {
          "text": "Efwf,non-CO2 \ntCO2e/TJ \n26.23 \nNon-CO2 emission factor of \nbiomass that is substituted \nor reduced",
          "page": 50,
          "paragraph_id": "p50-22",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        },
        {
          "text": "Bold \ntonnes/year \n5.49 \nQuantity of biomass \nconsumed in baseline",
          "page": 50,
          "paragraph_id": "p50-31",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        },
        {
          "text": "The project adopts a gross-to-net adjustment factor of 95% on emissions reductions to \naccount for leakage as described under the methodology VMR0006, Section 8.3.",
          "page": 21,
          "paragraph_id": "p21-10",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        },
        {
          "text": "Leakage shall be considered as default 0.95 in accordance with Section 8.3 of the applied \nmethodology VRM0006 v1.",
          "page": 46,
          "paragraph_id": "p46-08",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        },
        {
          "text": "0.95 \nDiscount factor to account for leakage.",
          "page": 47,
          "paragraph_id": "p47-15",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        },
        {
          "text": "A net gross leakage factor of 0.95 is applied to ERy,i,j.",
          "page": 48,
          "paragraph_id": "p48-16",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        },
        {
          "text": "DF \nfraction \n0.95 \nDefault leakage adjustment \nfactor",
          "page": 50,
          "paragraph_id": "p50-30",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        },
        {
          "text": "from PI1-K2C. Based on the initial number of ICS planned for PI1-K2C and taking the \nexpected 5-year operational lifetime of the ICS into account, the GP’s ex-ante ERs were \nmodelled to represent a conservative approximation. Although the expected lifetime of the \ntechnology is 5 years, it is assumed that some of the devices will still be operational after \nthe 5-year period. For ex-ante estimations, a decreasing operation rate of stoves (“drop off \nrate”) of 2.5% per year was incorporated into the ER calculation for the 10-year crediting \nperiod.",
          "page": 15,
          "paragraph_id": "p15-04",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        },
        {
          "text": "0.94 \nAdjustment factor to account for uncertainty related to \nproject cookstove efficiency test.",
          "page": 48,
          "paragraph_id": "p48-06",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        },
        {
          "text": "Data from the monitoring survey will be collected at least \nbiennially and applied to the emissions reductions \ncalculations during that monitoring period. Where the required \nlevel of precision is not met either additional surveys may be \ncompleted, or the lower bound value applied.",
          "page": 55,
          "paragraph_id": "p55-08",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        },
        {
          "text": "Where the required level of precision is not met either \nadditional monitoring activities may be completed, or the lower \nbound value applied.",
          "page": 56,
          "paragraph_id": "p56-10",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        },
        {
          "text": "Where the required level of precision is not met either \nadditional monitoring activities may be completed, or the lower \nbound value applied.",
          "page": 57,
          "paragraph_id": "p57-09",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        },
        {
          "text": "Data from the monitoring survey will be collected at least \nonce every two years and applied to the emissions reductions \ncalculations during that monitoring period. Where the required \nlevel of precision is not met either additional surveys may be \ncompleted, or the lower bound value applied.",
          "page": 58,
          "paragraph_id": "p58-09",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        },
        {
          "text": "If the required level of precision is not achieved, then further surveys may be completed or the \nlower bound value adopted in the calculations.",
          "page": 64,
          "paragraph_id": "p64-02",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        },
        {
          "text": "The total number of devices in operation compared to the total \nnumber of distributed (according to the monitoring database) \nwill be surveyed.",
          "page": 54,
          "paragraph_id": "p54-20",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        },
        {
          "text": "Devices in operation in the sampled group will be counted \nduring each monitoring period to derive an attrition rate \n(expressed as a percentage) and this percentage deduction \nwill be applied to the total number of devices operating.",
          "page": 54,
          "paragraph_id": "p54-22",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        },
        {
          "text": "Monitoring equipment \nWhen measured: as specified in WBT protocol",
          "page": 56,
          "paragraph_id": "p56-06",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        },
        {
          "text": "Data will be collected annually and applied to the emissions \nreductions calculations during that monitoring period.",
          "page": 56,
          "paragraph_id": "p56-09",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        },
        {
          "text": "Monitoring equipment \nAs specified in KPT protocol",
          "page": 57,
          "paragraph_id": "p57-06",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        },
        {
          "text": "The actual operation of stoves is monitored via parameter \n𝑵𝑵𝑵𝑵,𝒊𝒊,𝒋𝒋 and therefore any stove found to be in operation beyond \nits expected lifetime may still be credited during the PI crediting \nperiod. Likewise, stoves found not to be in operation prior to \nthe end of their lifetime will be discounted.",
          "page": 60,
          "paragraph_id": "p60-15",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        },
        {
          "text": "Field-based monitoring activities to determine monitored parameter values will be either a field \nsurvey, KPT or WBT.",
          "page": 63,
          "paragraph_id": "p63-05",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        },
        {
          "text": "Data shall be recorded for each activity either directly onto a smartphone-based app designed for \nthe purpose, or via paper forms where this is not possible.",
          "page": 63,
          "paragraph_id": "p63-06",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        },
        {
          "text": "Data collection will be conducted by a dedicated monitoring team of trained individuals, either from \nTASC SA or the Project Instance Implementer. The monitoring team will use a survey \nquestionnaire and instruments required for KPT/WBT measurements on the sampled ICS.",
          "page": 63,
          "paragraph_id": "p63-10",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        },
        {
          "text": "Completed survey questionnaires and KPT/WBT data will be collected by the monitoring team and \ndelivered to the TASC SA Carbon Project Manager for analysis. These shall be checked through \nfor errors and completeness, and compiled into a monitoring report. Any incomplete or missing \ndata shall be documented clearly. The monitoring report will include:",
          "page": 64,
          "paragraph_id": "p64-05",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        }
      ],
      "dropped_findings": 0,
      "review_flags": [],
      "excerpt": {
        "paragraphs": [
          "p3-02",
          "p3-03",
          "p3-04",
          "p3-05",
          "p3-06",
          "p3-07",
          "p3-08",
          "p3-09",
          "p3-10",
          "p8-09",
          "p8-11",
          "p8-12",
          "p8-13",
          "p8-14",
          "p11-03",
          "p11-04",
          "p11-05",
          "p11-08",
          "p11-09",
          "p11-10",
          "p11-11",
          "p11-12",
          "p11-13",
          "p11-14",
          "p13-14",
          "p13-15",
          "p14-11",
          "p15-03",
          "p15-04",
          "p15-05",
          "p17-05",
          "p17-06",
          "p21-10",
          "p22-02",
          "p22-03",
          "p24-02",
          "p24-03",
          "p24-04",
          "p24-05",
          "p24-06",
          "p30-03",
          "p30-04",
          "p30-05",
          "p32-05",
          "p32-06",
          "p32-07",
          "p35-07",
          "p35-08",
          "p35-14",
          "p35-15",
          "p35-16",
          "p36-06",
          "p36-07",
          "p36-08",
          "p43-06",
          "p43-07",
          "p44-04",
          "p44-05",
          "p44-06",
          "p44-07",
          "p44-08",
          "p44-09",
          "p44-10",
          "p45-02",
          "p45-03",
          "p46-04",
          "p46-06",
          "p46-08",
          "p46-09",
          "p47-11",
          "p47-12",
          "p47-13",
          "p47-14",
          "p47-15",
          "p47-16",
          "p48-05",
          "p48-06",
          "p48-07",
          "p48-16",
          "p49-02",
          "p49-03",
          "p49-04",
          "p49-10",
          "p49-11",
          "p49-12",
          "p49-13",
          "p49-14",
          "p50-10",
          "p50-11",
          "p50-12",
          "p50-13",
          "p50-14",
          "p50-20",
          "p50-22",
          "p50-30",
          "p50-31",
          "p52-11",
          "p52-12",
          "p52-15",
          "p52-16",
          "p53-02",
          "p53-10",
          "p53-11",
          "p53-19",
          "p53-20",
          "p54-13",
          "p54-20",
          "p54-22",
          "p55-08",
          "p55-09",
          "p56-02",
          "p56-05",
          "p56-06",
          "p56-09",
          "p56-10",
          "p56-11",
          "p57-06",
          "p57-08",
          "p57-09",
          "p57-10",
          "p57-12",
          "p57-18",
          "p58-02",
          "p58-03",
          "p58-09",
          "p58-10",
          "p58-11",
          "p59-19",
          "p59-20",
          "p59-21",
          "p59-22",
          "p59-24",
          "p60-14",
          "p60-15",
          "p60-16",
          "p61-07",
          "p61-08",
          "p61-13",
          "p62-02",
          "p62-04",
          "p62-06",
          "p62-08",
          "p62-09",
          "p63-03",
          "p63-05",
          "p63-06",
          "p63-07",
          "p63-09",
          "p63-10",
          "p63-12",
          "p64-02",
          "p64-03",
          "p64-05",
          "p64-06",
          "p64-08",
          "p64-10",
          "p64-11"
        ],
        "chars": 29863
      }
    },
    {
      "principle": "no_double_counting",
      "status": "partial_evidence",
      "score": 67,
      "rationale": "Evidence found for 2 of 3 checks (D1, D2); not found in the excerpt: D3.",
      "checks": [
        {
          "id": "D1",
          "question": "Does the text state whether the project is registered, or issues credits, under another GHG program (e.g. CDM, Gold Standard)?",
          "answer": "yes",
          "evidence": [
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p20-10",
              "page": 20,
              "text": "This is a new project and has not been registered or seeking registration under any other \nGHG programs."
            }
          ],
          "second_opinion_p_yes": 0.75,
          "needs_review": false,
          "dropped": null
        },
        {
          "id": "D2",
          "question": "Does the text address other environmental credits or certificates (e.g. renewable energy certificates, I-RECs) or participation in an emissions trading scheme?",
          "answer": "yes",
          "evidence": [
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p21-05",
              "page": 21,
              "text": "The project is not included in an emissions trading program or any other mechanism that \nincludes GHG allowance trading."
            },
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p21-07",
              "page": 21,
              "text": "The project has not sought, nor received another form of GHG-related environmental \ncredit."
            }
          ],
          "second_opinion_p_yes": 0.88,
          "needs_review": false,
          "dropped": null
        },
        {
          "id": "D3",
          "question": "Does the text address the host country's national accounting or registry, or a corresponding adjustment?",
          "answer": "no",
          "evidence": [],
          "second_opinion_p_yes": 0.08,
          "needs_review": false,
          "dropped": null
        }
      ],
      "quotes": [
        {
          "text": "This is a new project and has not been registered or seeking registration under any other \nGHG programs.",
          "page": 20,
          "paragraph_id": "p20-10",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        },
        {
          "text": "The project is not included in an emissions trading program or any other mechanism that \nincludes GHG allowance trading.",
          "page": 21,
          "paragraph_id": "p21-05",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        },
        {
          "text": "The project has not sought, nor received another form of GHG-related environmental \ncredit.",
          "page": 21,
          "paragraph_id": "p21-07",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        }
      ],
      "dropped_findings": 0,
      "review_flags": [],
      "excerpt": {
        "paragraphs": [
          "p2-16",
          "p2-17",
          "p2-18",
          "p20-07",
          "p20-08",
          "p20-09",
          "p20-10",
          "p21-02",
          "p21-04",
          "p21-05",
          "p21-07",
          "p21-08",
          "p28-06",
          "p28-07",
          "p35-06",
          "p35-07",
          "p35-08",
          "p35-16",
          "p35-17",
          "p35-18",
          "p37-05",
          "p37-06",
          "p37-07",
          "p37-08",
          "p37-15",
          "p37-16",
          "p37-17",
          "p38-04",
          "p38-05",
          "p38-06",
          "p38-07",
          "p39-08",
          "p39-09",
          "p39-10",
          "p44-03",
          "p44-04",
          "p44-05",
          "p44-06",
          "p44-10",
          "p44-11",
          "p52-15",
          "p52-16",
          "p61-13",
          "p61-16",
          "p61-17",
          "p61-18"
        ],
        "chars": 8694
      }
    },
    {
      "principle": "safeguards",
      "status": "partial_evidence",
      "score": 75,
      "rationale": "Evidence found for 3 of 4 checks (S1, S2, S4); not found in the excerpt: S3.",
      "checks": [
        {
          "id": "S1",
          "question": "Does the text describe a stakeholder consultation with specifics such as dates, places, participants or comments received?",
          "answer": "yes",
          "evidence": [
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p23-06",
              "page": 23,
              "text": "i. \nOnline \nmeeting, \n22/01/2021 \nii. \nWebinar, \n22/04/2021 \niii. \nSedawa \nMunicipal Hall, \n11/05/2021 \niv. \nLulekani \nMunicipal Hall, \n12/05/2021 \nv. \nBrooklyn \nNazarene \nChurch, \n13/05/2021 \nvi. \nMnisi \nTribal \nHall, \n14/05/2021"
            }
          ],
          "second_opinion_p_yes": 0.97,
          "needs_review": false,
          "dropped": null
        },
        {
          "id": "S2",
          "question": "Does the text describe a grievance or complaint mechanism through which affected people can raise concerns?",
          "answer": "yes",
          "evidence": [
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p30-06",
              "page": 30,
              "text": "Stakeholders \nhave \nbeen provided with the \ncontact details of K2C \nand TASC during the \nstakeholder \nconsultations and at \nthe point of distribution. \n  \nGrievances \nmay \nbe \nreported telephonically, \nvia email or in person \nto \nK2C \nor \nTASC, \ncontact details of which \nare provided on all \nproject documentation, \nincluding \nthe \nnon-\ntechnical summary and \nthe \n‘how \nto \nguide’ \nprovided to all end \nusers. \n \nGrievances \nwill \nbe \naddressed by the IP or \nthe TASC PI manager \nand reported. These \nshall be dealt with as \nfollows: \n- \nBy responding to \nthe stakeholder in"
            }
          ],
          "second_opinion_p_yes": 0.98,
          "needs_review": false,
          "dropped": null
        },
        {
          "id": "S3",
          "question": "Does the text report an environmental impact assessment or an analysis of the project's environmental risks?",
          "answer": "no",
          "evidence": [],
          "second_opinion_p_yes": 0.76,
          "needs_review": true,
          "dropped": null
        },
        {
          "id": "S4",
          "question": "Does the text address the rights of local communities or indigenous peoples, such as free, prior and informed consent (FPIC) or benefit sharing?",
          "answer": "yes",
          "evidence": [
            {
              "paragraph_id": "p28-11",
              "page": 28,
              "text": "1) The project proponent \nshall \nrecognize, \nrespect and support \nlocal \nstakeholders’ \nproperty \nrights \nand \nwhere feasible, take \nmeasures \nto \nhelp \nsecure \nrights. \nThe \nproject \nshall \nnot \nencroach on private, \nstakeholder \nor \ngovernment property \nor relocate people off \ntheir \nlands \nwithout \nconsent. The project \nmay affect property \nrights if free, prior and \ninformed consent is \nobtained from those \nconcerned \nand \na"
            }
          ],
          "second_opinion_p_yes": 0.86,
          "needs_review": false,
          "dropped": null
        }
      ],
      "quotes": [
        {
          "text": "i. \nOnline \nmeeting, \n22/01/2021 \nii. \nWebinar, \n22/04/2021 \niii. \nSedawa \nMunicipal Hall, \n11/05/2021 \niv. \nLulekani \nMunicipal Hall, \n12/05/2021 \nv. \nBrooklyn \nNazarene \nChurch, \n13/05/2021 \nvi. \nMnisi \nTribal \nHall, \n14/05/2021",
          "page": 23,
          "paragraph_id": "p23-06",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        },
        {
          "text": "Stakeholders \nhave \nbeen provided with the \ncontact details of K2C \nand TASC during the \nstakeholder \nconsultations and at \nthe point of distribution. \n  \nGrievances \nmay \nbe \nreported telephonically, \nvia email or in person \nto \nK2C \nor \nTASC, \ncontact details of which \nare provided on all \nproject documentation, \nincluding \nthe \nnon-\ntechnical summary and \nthe \n‘how \nto \nguide’ \nprovided to all end \nusers. \n \nGrievances \nwill \nbe \naddressed by the IP or \nthe TASC PI manager \nand reported. These \nshall be dealt with as \nfollows: \n- \nBy responding to \nthe stakeholder in",
          "page": 30,
          "paragraph_id": "p30-06",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        },
        {
          "text": "1) The project proponent \nshall \nrecognize, \nrespect and support \nlocal \nstakeholders’ \nproperty \nrights \nand \nwhere feasible, take \nmeasures \nto \nhelp \nsecure \nrights. \nThe \nproject \nshall \nnot \nencroach on private, \nstakeholder \nor \ngovernment property \nor relocate people off \ntheir \nlands \nwithout \nconsent. The project \nmay affect property \nrights if free, prior and \ninformed consent is \nobtained from those \nconcerned \nand \na",
          "page": 28,
          "paragraph_id": "p28-11",
          "verification": "cited_paragraph"
        }
      ],
      "dropped_findings": 0,
      "review_flags": [
        "models_disagree:S3"
      ],
      "excerpt": {
        "paragraphs": [
          "p2-19",
          "p2-20",
          "p2-21",
          "p2-22",
          "p2-23",
          "p2-24",
          "p2-25",
          "p2-26",
          "p4-03",
          "p4-04",
          "p5-02",
          "p5-09",
          "p5-10",
          "p5-11",
          "p6-07",
          "p6-08",
          "p11-07",
          "p11-08",
          "p11-09",
          "p11-12",
          "p11-13",
          "p11-14",
          "p18-02",
          "p22-06",
          "p22-07",
          "p22-16",
          "p22-17",
          "p22-19",
          "p22-20",
          "p23-02",
          "p23-03",
          "p23-04",
          "p23-05",
          "p23-06",
          "p23-07",
          "p23-08",
          "p24-02",
          "p24-03",
          "p24-04",
          "p24-05",
          "p24-06",
          "p24-07",
          "p24-08",
          "p25-02",
          "p25-03",
          "p25-04",
          "p25-05",
          "p25-06",
          "p25-07",
          "p25-08",
          "p25-09",
          "p26-02",
          "p26-03",
          "p27-02",
          "p27-03",
          "p27-04",
          "p27-05",
          "p27-06",
          "p27-07",
          "p28-02",
          "p28-03",
          "p28-04",
          "p28-06",
          "p28-07",
          "p28-08",
          "p28-09",
          "p28-10",
          "p28-11",
          "p29-04",
          "p29-07",
          "p29-08",
          "p29-09",
          "p29-11",
          "p29-12",
          "p29-13",
          "p30-03",
          "p30-04",
          "p30-05",
          "p30-06",
          "p31-05",
          "p31-06",
          "p31-07",
          "p31-08",
          "p31-10",
          "p33-02",
          "p33-03",
          "p33-05",
          "p33-06",
          "p33-07",
          "p34-02",
          "p34-03",
          "p35-11",
          "p35-12",
          "p35-13",
          "p35-14",
          "p35-15",
          "p35-16",
          "p61-07",
          "p61-08"
        ],
        "chars": 28372
      }
    }
  ],
  "overall": {
    "score": 66,
    "included": [
      "additionality",
      "robust_quantification",
      "no_double_counting",
      "safeguards"
    ],
    "excluded": [
      "permanence"
    ],
    "weights": {
      "additionality": 0.25,
      "permanence": 0.2,
      "robust_quantification": 0.25,
      "no_double_counting": 0.15,
      "safeguards": 0.15
    }
  },
  "disclaimer": "Signal, not verdict. Each check says whether a specific kind of evidence is present in an excerpt of the submitted documents, not whether the evidence is true. Scores are not an ICVCM assessment, a rating of the project, or a statement about its real-world impact.",
  "generated_at": "2026-10-19T16:49:08+00:00"
}